Thursday, September 2, 2010
Click for Denver, Colorado Forecast
Search

CSU

Paramount

Facebook

Downtown Denver Partnership

Nuggets

 

Compromise on universal health care attempted

Lawmaker wants mix of private and government coverage

Gene Davis, DDN Staff Writer

Thursday, April 23, 2009

 


After watching a bill that would provide government-run universal health care get effectively killed earlier this month, Littleton Democrat Rep. Joe Rice is introducing a bill that he hopes will strike a compromise between opposing parties and will further the conversation on improved health care for Colorado.

The Comprehensive Health Care Reform Act would combine private and public insurance systems. Under House Bill 1358, the government would be in charge of covering preventive and catastrophic care, but Coloradans would be required to purchase individual insurance policies to cover everything else.

Rice told the Denver Daily News yesterday that including private insurers in the health care reform conversation would keep the price tag for the reform reasonable. According to the bill, there is enough money in the current health care system to fund the Comprehensive Health Care Reform Act.

“I think that without having some incentive to look at a plan that’s cheaper, there’s no incentive for cost control,” Rice said.

Health Care For All Colorado publicly spoke out against the bill yesterday, saying the bill would increase the reliance on for-profit insurance while increasing the cost of health care in Colorado. Rice called most of Health Care For All Colorado’s arguments wrong, saying that it’s “not an increased reliance on private health care, it’s decreased reliance on private health care.”  The lawmaker added that Health Care For All Colorado is opposing the bill because it’s not the government- run universal health care bill that the group desires.

However, the bill that would have provided government-run universal health care was laid over earlier this month until July and isn’t expected to pass.

“We tried single payer, we supported single payer, single payer didn’t work,” Rice said.

Health Care For All Colorado also argued that Colorado should not penalize those who do not purchase for-profit insurance, and that mandating the purchase of minimum benefits will increase the number of people in the state who are underinsured.

Meanwhile, supporters say that mandating health care for everyone would prevent the cost-shifting that occurs when all Coloradans pay for people who are uninsured and when providers raise rates due to reimbursement for services and inadequate Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement rates. 


Agreement possible?

According to Rice, both single payer and business community advocates came to an 85-percent agreement on health care reform this year, but talks broke down over the role of private insurance and “hotheads prevailed and they walked away.”

Rice said he is hoping to grow the center of support for health care reform by striking a compromise between the two groups. However, he knows it won’t be easy and is geared up for the contentious debate that is likely to begin when the bill is introduced in committee on Friday.

“The process going through this will likely prove my point; (single-payer advocates and the business community) can kill each other’s plans and say, ‘Yeah, we won, but, you know, we’re still stuck with the same messy system,” he said. 

Rice obviously hopes his plan succeeds, but if it doesn’t, he hopes both sides will decide, “Gosh, we each killed each other’s plans, we need to sit down again and come up with something again for next year.”

Rice said if the two sides continue to battle each other,  “then they can continue to fight each other for a very, very, very long time.”

 

Comments:
H Krening @ 2009-04-24 09:52:51As a breast cancer survivor and someone whose late husband lost a long battle with cancer, I am opposed to any “compromise” or further descent into socialized medicine. The excellent care available to us came at a cost, of course! I would never have asked the medical providers to work for free nor would I have asked my neighbors to foot the bill. Medical insurance was a non-negotiable necessity long before we needed it. Those of us who live in the real world are learning that government involvement in health care results in waste and poor care, never mind the loss of freedom to those who are forced to "choose" according to its rules. Government should get out of health care and allow a truly private system (not one shackled by mandates and regulations) to return to US medicine. I have elderly parents and a daughter in the military, and all I see is waste, shoddy care and a lack of freedom from government. Added to that injustice is the fact that the cost is covered by forcing one group to pay for another. And all that makes the news is “compromise” to protect and increase government power over my health care issues. We are not talking about some peripheral issue, but the quality of life itself. There are alternative ideas out there. These ideas need to be considered before it is too late.
Flag this comment as Inappropriate / Spam
Walter Boggs @ 2009-04-25 13:55:46But I don't want to buy government insurance for catastrophic and preventive care. I want to buy private insurance for that. Government coverage will simply drive private insurers out of these markets, as it has done elsewhere. Can I buy that coverage from an insurer in another state? Sorry, that's not permitted either.
Flag this comment as Inappropriate / Spam

 

Add a new comment...
Spammers: links do not work and our site gets monitored for spam daily and your comments will be removed -- please do not spam our site!
Your Name:
Your Email:
Title:
Comments:
If you are viewing this page with a screen reader or non-graphical browser, you may manually request registration by contacting us
Please copy the characters from this image into the box below. All characters are either numbers 1-9 (not zero) or letters (upper and lowercase). If you cannot read this image, you can click it to try a different image (most browsers). Otherwise, submit the page anyway and try again.
Image Text:
Liquor Store

AVS

Trinity

Twitter-Daily Deal

AFW